A lenda diz que São João escreveu os Evangelhos em Efes a pedido de outros disciplos e que faleceu na Igreja com o seu nome no Monte de Ayasoluk.
The 13th-century Golden Legend narrates John's death as follows:
When Sunday arrived, all the people gathered in the church that had been built in his name, and John preached to them at cockcrow, exhorting them to be steadfast in the faith, and zealous in carrying out the commandments of God. Then he had them dig a square grave near the altar and throw the earth outside the church.
He went down into the grave and, with arms outstretched to God, said: 'Lord Jesus Christ, you have called me to your feast: here I am, and I thank you for deigning to invite me to your table. You know that I have longed for you with all my heart!' When he had said this, he was surrounded by a light so brilliant that he was lost to human sight. Then, when the light faded, the grave was found to be full of manna. This manna is still produced there to this day, and it covers the floor of the grave, looking rather like the fine grains of sand at the bottom of a spring.
Com o declínio da importância de Efes e as invasões dos Árabes, esta foi convertida a uma Mesquita em 1330. O edifício foi totalmente destruído em 1402 pelo exército Mongol e por sismos.
